Innovation-Unit Overhauls: Visa and MasterCard Retool to Stay Competitive
Recent posts on this blog
For at least the past six months to a year, the big card networks, Visa Inc. and MasterCard Worldwide, have been reorganizing their innovation teamsâmuch of it behind the scenesâas they try to avoid missing out on the opportunity offered by mobile payment.
That opportunity has so far eluded them, and contactless cardsâperhaps their last major payment innovationâare stagnating, especially in the U.S.
Of course, the big card schemes are making investments, conducting trials, drafting specifications and pitching âsolutionsâ to their customers, the banks, to promote remote payment, mobile-money transfers and Near Field Communication.
But observers see very little happening on the ground so far, except, as one observer wryly noted, the success the card schemes seem to have had in putting apps on phones to help U.S. consumers find the nearest ATM. â(That) is kind of funny because these guys are trying to replace paper cash,â he said.
To be sure, Visa and MasterCard canât make NFC phones appear out of thin air or deploy contactless point-of-sale terminals across major retailer chains (more than theyâve already done so by subsidy), or roll out remote payment or mobile transfers. They can only propose standard and secure products and services to banks, along with help in bringing them to market.
But the mass of banks are not buying it yet.
âI talk to a lot of banks, and the case has not been clearly made (by the card networks),â Red Gillen, senior analyst in the banking group of U.S.-based research and consulting firm Celent, recently told me. Visa, as âking of the payment hill,â has a responsibility to fill in the blanks for banks on how they could make revenue from mobile, he said.
Mobile Threats
Meanwhile, threats to the banksâ payments business are growing as the iPhone and its ilkâand more recently contactless peripherals for mobile phonesâgive third-party payments players an opening to tap the mobile channel.
Those threats have increased in urgency over the past few months as details dribble out about plans by the giant U.S. mobile operators to possibly launch mobile-payment services or even their own payment scheme.
Sources said Visa began making changes in its product development team about six months ago or so, though the concerns about the effectiveness of the innovation unit go back further.
In large part, the concerns led to Visa going outside the organization and to the mobile industry for its new head of mobile. The card organization announced the appointment last month of Bill Gajda, who is chief commercial officer of the GSM Association, where he has overseen mobile-money transfer and NFC Pay-Buy Mobile initiatives for the large mobile operator trade group.
UPDATE: Visa said he would report directly to Elizabeth Buse, who is currently global head of product at Visa, bypassing Tim Attinger, who is global head of product innovation. Attinger had already been relieved of his title as head of product development last year. So, it looks like Attinger is out at Visa. Pam Zuercher also left her post last year as head of mobile, for a position involving sales. But Buse will be named group president for the Asia-Pacific and CEMEA (Central and Eastern Europe, Middle East and Africa) regions, NFC Times has learned, meaning Visa will appoint a new global head of product.
Kranzley To Leave MasterCard
Over at MasterCard, there is definitely a changing of the guard in the innovation unit.
The card network a little more than a year appointed Joshua Peirez as its first group executive for innovative platforms. The 30-something lawyer by training has been expanding MasterCardâs MoneySend funds-transfer program and its inControl transaction-control system and playing up their mobile possibilities.
Peirez took MoneySend global this year, with transfers available via MasterCard or Maestro cards or accountsâif banks roll the program out. MasterCard hopes to develop MoneySend as a network-based service enabling consumers to transfer funds P2P or to send cross-border remittances.
Mobile P2P, however, has failed to take off for any provider in developed countries. And remittances pose particular challenges for card networks since recipients usually live in poor countries with limited access to payment cards or banks.
Like Visaâs contactless application, payWave, MasterCard PayPass is growing only slowly. And its early promoter, Art Kranzley, MasterCardâs chief emerging technology officer and the so-called father of PayPass, is stepping down this spring, MasterCard confirmed to NFC Times. Kranzley is retiring after 22 years with the card company, said MasterCard.
Kranzley was instrumental in the launch of PayPass five years ago in the United States and, therefore, was key in the roll out of contactless bank cards around the world. He also had a strong hand in launching MoneySend.
Kranzleyâs departure follows the retirement of Toni Merschen last year, MasterCardâs long-time head of chip programs, based in Waterloo, Belgium. Simon Pugh, MasterCardâs chief of mobile, left quietly at the end of 2009.
As the Visa and MasterCard innovation units try to resurrect the sense of anticipation many banks once felt for contactless, they are looking to mobile phones. According to Peirez, through a spokeswoman, MasterCard continues to work on NFC, along with related technologies, such as contactless microSD cards. There were no specifics, however.
Tiny Payment Cards
Visa, on the other hand, made clear its high hopes for contactless microSD cards, announcing Feb. 15 at the Mobile World Congress in Barcelona plans to launch a microSD packing payWave.
As NFC Times reported yesterday, makers of the new kind of contactless cardsâwhich can bring the connectivity and user interface of the mobile phone to contactless payment without the wait for real NFCâare readying their wares.
One of those card suppliers, U.S.-based DeviceFidelity, is under contract with Visa to develop a payWave contactless microSD. Visa will begin field trials with banks in the second quarter.
The exclusive agreement looks like a mini-coup for Visa, since it locks in a leading developer of the technology in DeviceFidelity, and keeps that companyâs cards away from those that would introduce contactless-mobile payment under another brand.
Although, as DeviceFidelityâs CEO Deepak Jain, told me, if U.S. mobile operators were to launch their own payment service using contactless microSDs, they would need cards with a certified application onboard. And Visa is expected to be the first to have them with his payWave-enabled In2Pay cards.
âBoth financial institutions and wireless carriers can deploy it freely with peace of mind,â he said.
It seems unlikely the mobile operators would work with Visa if they launched mobile payment, however. The telcos would probably seek more freedom to develop their own payment services, earning revenue from merchant fees and other services.
So for the revamped innovation teams at Visa and MasterCard, there will likely be no peace of mind until their brands greet mobile-packing consumers on handset screens at the point of sale.
Dan Balaban is editor of NFC Times.