Report: Japan’s M-Payment Players Discover That Points Count

Jun 14 2010

Without points programs, coupons and other incentives, mass adoption of contactless-mobile payment will not happen in Japan.

That’s one of the main conclusions of a report released Monday by U.S.-based research and consulting firm Celent on Japan’s contactless-wallet rollout.

According to veteran Japan-watcher Red Gillen, author of the report, major backers of the contactless-mobile payment rollout in Japan, including dominant telco NTT DoCoMo, acknowledge they should have emphasized promotions and other reward programs a lot earlier than they did.

“Payments are a commodity; they (consumers) want points,” Gillen told NFC Times. “If it weren’t for points or promotions, adoption would be drastically lower.”

Moreover, Japanese merchants haven’t been “particularly interested in speed and cash-handling benefits” offered by contactless-mobile payment. Like consumers, they are interested in promotions the handset and mobile network can offer, said Gillen.

Japan boasts the largest deployment of contactless-mobile phones in the world by far, a rollout that began six years ago. More than 60 million phones carrying the NFC-like FeliCa chip from Japan’s Sony Corp. are in circulation, which can be used for a range of services, including transit ticketing, airline check-in and building access.

But payment has always been the premier application backers have promoted. And according to DoCoMo, more than 1.1 million shops now accept a range of contactless-payment applications that subscribers can download or activate. That figure probably includes vending machines and taxis.

Yet, most independent observers agree take-up of contactless-mobile payment by Japanese consumers has been disappointing.

Tapping for Teriyaki McBurger Discounts
But among the most popular services involving payment on Japan’s contactless wallet phones is “Kazasu Coupon,” a loyalty program offered by McDonald’s restaurants in Japan as part of a joint venture with DoCoMo.

Subscribers download coupons over the air just as they have done for years from McDonald’s Japan’s high-traffic Web site, which customers access both by phone and PC. But instead of showing the coupon on the phone screen to the clerk and paying with cash, customers can place their orders, redeem their coupons and pay the tab–all with just one or two taps of their wallet phones. The customers can punch in their food and drink orders on their handsets while waiting in line or even before leaving home.

All of the nearly 4,000 McDonald’s restaurants in Japan are equipped with contactless readers. According to a Japanese media report, 4.5 million subscribers had signed up for the Kazasu Coupon offer as of August 2009, less than 18 months after the launch of the program. Neither McDonald’s nor DoCoMo has released transaction figures, however.

“This kind of idea is becoming very popular, so many types of service providers start to implement these types of services,” said Hiroshi Tamano, head of DoCoMo’s European office, who spoke at this week’s Mobile Payment 2010 conference in Paris.

Most of the more than 16 million registered users of the McDonald’s Japan Web site still don’t use it in concert with the FeliCa chip in their phones. But McDonald’s doesn’t have to wait for customers to visit the site. The fast-food chain can push coupons to customers’ phones based on their purchasing history, noted Tamano.

Another example of a payment-service provider combining payment with loyalty is the contactless e-purse Edy, which cobrands with airlines, enabling customers to earn points and also to convert their yen in their Edy accounts to miles or their miles to yen.

Mobile Payments Hard to Quantify
Edy was the first payment application available on wallet phones, which DoCoMo introduced in July 2004, followed by other telcos. Japan has at least eight contactless payment schemes, most available on both cards and phones. DoCoMo launched its own payment brand, iD, in December 2005 and its own credit-payment service, DCMX, flying under the brand six months later.

Payment has been DoCoMo’s main business case for its large investment in the contactless-mobile rollout. It collects merchant and brand fees when consumers pay with DCMX and iD. But payment has yet to return DoCoMo's investment, sources agree.

As of March, there were 14.2 million subscribers registered for iD, of which 11.3 million were DCMX customers. And most of those were DCMX mini subscribers, who only require a quick opt-in to sign up for the service. They can then spend up to 10,000 yen (US$109) per month tapping their phones at iD terminals, with the transactions appearing on their phone bills.

DoCoMo’s Tamano told NFC Times the telco’s payment service is capturing enough low-value transactions, including purchases at the scores of convenience stores that accept iD and other contactless-payment brands. But mid- to high-value transactions were lagging. “It’s not the number of transactions; the amount used for each transaction is not up to our expectations,” he said.

Some observers believe low-value transactions are also less than expected. Among other things, many Japanese consumers still perceive the wallet phones as insecure, despite safeguards put in place by DoCoMo and other service providers. In addition, Japan is still a cash-based culture.

DoCoMo and other payment-service providers have not released transaction figures of any kind, either low or high value. So estimates of how often Japanese consumers tap their phones to pay is hard to come by.

Celent’s Gillen estimates there are 28 million registered mobile-payment accounts in Japan. Of those, roughly 20 million are “active,” which Gillen loosely defines as an account the subscriber uses at least once a month. A single subscriber could have multiple payment accounts on his phone.

Although it’s hard to be certain of the number of active mobile-payment accounts in Japan, one thing Gillen is fairly sure of is that m-payment transactions would increase if they were tied to more incentives.

And while the Japanese experience often doesn’t translate well overseas, he said the use of wallet phones in Japan is instructive to players contemplating rollouts of contactless-mobile services elsewhere. For example, it’s of special interest in such markets as the United States, where, like Japan, mobile operators, retailers and other nonbanks have been gearing up to offer mobile payment.

“That’s the big lesson (from Japan),” he told NFC Times. “They love points programs. They love coupons.”

Article comments

 
simage Sep 7 2010

People around the world today are using smart cards for debit and credit payments. Contactless payment applications are gaining momentum as new contactless devices are being introduced like Secure Contactless Tokens, NFC Stickers etc.As far as on security concern Dynamically generated codes, high encryption standards and biometrics can be employed in the security mechanisms for the contactless devices.
And very nice and informative news on contactless payment

Thanks

 
Kazmi Oct 14 2010

For dynamically code generation and strong encryption high processing is required and this processing will consume large amount of power consumption that is not good for power saving device like cell phone. And another important thing strong encryption will increase transection time as well. Memory in the smart devices is another obstacle to cope such issues.

Please register or login to post a comment.

HEADLINE NEWS

In-Depth: Tokenization Figures Demonstrate Majority of Mobile Payments Conducted Online

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight –  Recent research and forecasts have confirmed what industry observers already knew: Despite concerted efforts by the Pays wallets to gain widespread use of mobile payments in the U.S. at the physical point of sale, the large majority of mobile payments are conducted online, not by tapping NFC phones or wearables in stores.

Visa and Mastercard Forecast More Growth in Contactless in U.S., Spurred in Part by New York Fare Payments Service

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight - The heads of the two largest payments networks in the U.S., Visa and Mastercard, predict strong growth for contactless payments in the U.S., with Mastercard CEO Ajay Banga noting that 70% of U.S. Mastercard-branded cards in the U.S. are coming up for reissue over the next 12 to 14 months, and most of these cards will be issued with a contactless interface. A large number of Visa-branded cards will be reissued with a contactless interface during that period, as well.

Transport Officials in Sydney See Growing Demand for Contactless Fare Payments but Have No Plans to Retire Closed-Loop Opal

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Transport officials in Australia have released figures on use of contactless payments in Sydney and New South Wales, showing that customers tap their contactless credit and debit cards and NFC devices for an average of 1.5 million transactions per week, accounting for a relatively small but respectable number of transactions.

Insight: Moovit and Cubic Betting that MaaS Can Help U.S. Transit Agencies Regain Lost Ridership

Jan 24 2020

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – With public transit ridership decreasing in most large U.S. cities over the past five years, transit authorities are more open to becoming part of Mobility-as-a-Service platforms, which could potentially increase ridership for their rail and bus networks while offering customers options for the first and last mile. 

Philadelphia Transit Authority Confirms Plans for Launch of Open-Loop Payments after Delays

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – The Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority, or SEPTA, in Philadelphia plans to introduce open-loop payments of fares, with a pilot scheduled for around June, a spokesman confirmed to NFC Times. It makes SEPTA part of a small but growing number of U.S. transit agencies that are accepting payments of fares from contactless bank cards and NFC wallets or are planning to do so.

Contactless Payments of Fares Gets Slow Start in Miami, According to Figures

NFC TIMES Exclusive – Take-up of open-loop contactless payment of fares in Miami-Dade County, Fla., has been slow so far, more than four months after transit

Mobility as a Service Continues to Get Rolling with Uber Expanding Service to Second U.S. City

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Mobility as a service is expected to reshape the traditional transport industry, and while it is just getting rolling, the pace is starting to pick up. The latest bit of momentum came this week when global ride-hailing service Uber announced it will enable mass transit riders to buy and redeem tickets from its app in a second U.S. city, Las Vegas.

Contactless EMV Card Rollout in U.S. to Pick Up Speed in 2020, but Shape of Adoption Remains Unclear

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – With contactless EMV cards expected to have a significant footprint in the U.S. in 2020, the debate continues over whether the rollout will promote or harm take-up of NFC mobile payments and whether contactless open-loop transit payments will make a real impact on use of contactless at the retail point of sale.

More Open-Loop Transit Payments Services to Launch in Taiwan

Dec 24 2019

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Taiwan’s airport train service will begin accepting Visa- and Mastercard-branded credit cards starting next month, making it the second mass-transit service on the island nation to support open-loop payments for fares.

In-Depth: China Moving Forward On Face Payments of Transit Fares, Despite Some Hesitation by Users of Technology

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight –  More and more Chinese cities are trialing use of facial recognition technology for transit ticketing, a development that could enable users to avoid either cards or smartphones to pay fares on subways and other modes of transit.

Apple Launches Express Transit in London; Mobility Service also Adds NFC Payments Feature in Apple Wallet

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Apple has expanded its Express Transit service to another major market, enabling Apple Pay users to pay for fares on Transport for London-run trains and buses without first authenticating themselves on the NFC devices.

Analysis: Outlook Remains Dim for Bank Mobile Wallets as Another Major Bank Plans to Shut Down its Wallet App

NFC TIMES Exclusive Insight – Major Dutch bank ABN Amro will discontinue its NFC-enabled mobile wallet in January, a little more than three years after launching the app in late 2016, with the bank acknowledging that few customers use the service.