U.S. Mobile Operators Plan For 2011 Launch of NFC Payment

Aug 3 2010

U.S mobile carriers Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile USA hope to launch precommercial trials of their planned mobile-payment service in the third quarter of 2011, sources told NFC Times.

The precommercial launches, in perhaps three to four cities, could use the Zip contactless payment application from Discover Financial Services, stored on either SIM cards or embedded chips in the phones, sources said. Bridge technologies, such as contactless microSD cards, are also possible in addition to the NFC phones. An internal trial of the service could launch in the spring of 2011, though the planning for this and the precommercial launches remains fluid.

As Bloomberg financial news service reported today, the U.S. arm of UK-based Barclays bank would be involved in project as the banking partner. Discover would provide the merchant network.

That follows reports by NFC Times earlier this year of the joint venture among the three telcos and plans to launch a mobile payment service or their own payment scheme. Sprint was earlier involved in the project, as NFC Times first reported in February, but has dropped out. Representatives from the telcos and their expected partners continue to decline comment.

Discover has been seen as a likely partner since it has almost as much merchant penetration as Visa Inc. and MasterCard Worldwide in the U.S., both in terms of total merchant coverage and merchants equipped to take contactless payment from either cards or NFC phones. A relatively small percentage of total card-accepting merchants in the U.S. accept contactless so far, however.

More importantly, Discover appears to be more willing than Visa and MasterCard or their affiliated banks to cut a deal to share interchange and at a lower rate. Interchange revenue appears to be among the main business cases of the telcos for the mobile-payment service. But some observers believe the telcos see a substantial source of revenue from mobile advertising and marketing to their large base of subscribers that would be carrying NFC phones. 

The telcos would take on Visa and MasterCard and the big U.S. banks for a share of the billions of dollars worth of interchange fees. UPDATE: But the telcos' joint venture would have to offer lower interchange and, therefore, lower merchant fees to encourage more merchants to accept NFC-based payment, observers believe. END UPDATE. The telcos are likely talking to other American banks besides the Barclays U.S. unit. 

"If the reports are accurate, this new payment service would certainly upset a lot of apple carts," Red Gillen, senior analyst at U.S.-based research and consulting firm Celent told NFC Times. “This reported new payment service would undoubtedly spell bad news for Visa, MasterCard and their partner banks, who all along have been the assumed ‘inheritors’ of the U.S. mobile payments space."

It’s not yet certain the type of payment application–credit, debit or prepaid–that mobile carriers and their partners would launch, despite the assertion in the Bloomberg article that debit, along with credit, would be involved.

As Gillen points out, Barclays only issues credit cards in the U.S., through its Barclaycard arm. It does not offer retail banking stateside. Barclays or Discover could issue a credit application for the telcos, or the application might be prepaid, especially to start out with. For debit, Barclays would need to expand its banking operation in the U.S. or the telcos would have to bring in another banking partner. Though unlikely, the parties also could use decoupled debit, which would link the payment application to various bank accounts belonging to consumers. Barclays, as a banking partner for the joint venture, would store funds for customer payment accounts, if they are created and, of course, would help the mobile-payment scheme or service meet U.S. banking regulations. A Barclays spokesman said the bank has about 6 million credit cards on issue in the U.S.

The telcos could offer other applications related to payment, such as loyalty points good for airtime top-ups, or mobile couponing. That is in addition to possibly bringing in other service providers to the NFC platform, which could offer transit, entertainment ticketing or physical access control. 

Sources also told NFC Times that while the precommercial launches would happen in a handful of cities, they could not confirm reports that one of those is Atlanta, home of AT&T Mobility. Verizon and AT&T each has more than 90 million cellular subscribers in the U.S.

And the launches might be pushed back to later in 2011. The Verizon/AT&T/T-Mobile joint venture is still looking for a CEO. The telcos also haven’t yet hired a trusted service manager to download and manage the applications over the air. And perhaps the biggest unknown for the project is when enough NFC smartphone models will be available to make NFC launches viable.

Handset makers are working on models supporting Android and Symbian, which should be available next year. Research in Motion is also said to be working on NFC for some of its BlackBerry phones. And anticipation is again running high that Apple will incorporate NFC in its next iPhone. Apple reportedly recently hired a project manager for mobile commerce with a background in NFC.

But it generally takes 12 months or more after U.S. telcos order NFC before they can take delivery. At present, there are only one or two NFC models available for trials outside of China, including the 2G Samsung S5230.

It’s possible the U.S. telcos will not go forward with the mobile-payment service. If they do, much work remains to be completed before the launches.

In any case, interest in the U.S. in NFC among the major telcos is sure to add momentum to rollouts of the technology. Telcos and service providers in South Korea, China, France, the United Kingdom and elsewhere plan commercial launches next year. Together, the projects make it more likely handset makers will have a substantial portfolio of NFC models available for sale.


‘No Way We were Going to Ask for Half a Billion Dollars…’

Unlike other major transit agencies in the U.S., which have spent hundreds of millions of dollars replacing or upgrading their fare-collection systems, the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority has taken a different approach.

UK Bus Operator Go-Ahead Reports Cash Usage has Plummeted Because of Covid, While Contactless Transactions have Surged

The Go-Ahead Group, one of the big five privately owned public bus operators in the UK, said today it has seen cash usage on board the nearly 3,000 buses it runs in England outside of London fall to 23% of transactions, down from 53% three years ago.

Transit Operator Arriva Launches MaaS App in Netherlands; Hints at Expansion to Other European Countries

Arriva, one of the largest private transit operators in Europe, has launched a mobility-as-a-service app in the Netherlands, using white-label software from Israel-based trip-planning app provider

Cal-ITP: Agencies in California Could Hold ‘Several More’ Open-Loop Fare Payments Pilots

The California Integrated Travel Project, or Cal-ITP, is “on track to have at least several more” open-loop pilots or demonstration projects, a spokeswoman for the program told Mobility Payments.

Exclusive: Australia’s Transport for New South Wales Sees ‘Significant Increase’ in Use of Mobile Wallets by Riders

Mobile wallets now make up more than half of all contactless payments for Transport for New South Wales, Australia’s largest transit agency, the agency confirmed to Mobility Payments.

Start-Up Aims to Encourage More Taxi Drivers to Accept Bank Cards for Fares in Turkey

A Turkish start-up hopes to entice more taxi drivers to accept contactless credit and debit cards using SoftPOS terminals on Android smartphones, under a scheme being rolled out by the local fintec

Moscow Metro Launches Test of Facial Recognition Fare Payments Ahead of Rollout; Agency Says Masks Can Slow Verification

Moscow Metro announced that it is officially testing facial recognition-based fare payments at turnstiles, with plans to roll out the technology by the end of the year.

Major Transit Agency to Test Virtual Closed-Loop Cards with Google Pay

Aug 8 2021

Moscow Metro is launching a trial of a virtual version of its closed-loop Troika card that will be added to the Google Pay wallet, the agency announced Wednesday.

WMATA in D.C. Rolling Out New Terminals but has No Immediate Plans to Support Open Loop

The Washington (D.C.) Metropolitan Area Transit Authority last month started to replace 1,200 aging fare gates for its 91-station metro system and starting next year will do the same with 20-plus year-old fareboxes on board 1,500 buses, including upgraded readers for its closed-loop SmarTrip cards.

Visa Touts Growth in Contactless, Continues to Push Open-Loop Payments

Visa reported this week that contactless payments continued to climb as a percentage of all face-to-face transactions with its brand, mainly at retail, and among the uses the network is continuing to push for contactless is to pay for transit fares.

MaaS Global CEO: Transit Agencies Should Not Control MaaS Platforms

Sampo Hietanen, founder and CEO of Finland-based MaaS Global, agrees with most other industry experts that public transit should form the “core” of the mobility services on offer in any MaaS app or platform. But he contends that it would be a mistake for the agency itself to control the platform.

Case Study: German City First to Go Live with Check-in/be-out System in Country

Despite the growing popularity of contactless, NFC and QR-code technologies for electronic fare-collection, some transit agencies are experimenting with other technologies to collect fares.